top of page

The Mirage of Unattainable Goals: Why Leaders Setting Unrealistic Expectations Can’t Achieve Realistic Outcomes


Christopher E. Maynard


In the uncharted terrain of corporate strategy and leadership, the quest for growth often compels executives to paint rosy pictures, highlighting lofty aspirations for their teams. It is not uncommon for leaders to set high benchmarks and deadlines, hoping that the pressure and the challenge will ignite a drive in the team to reach new heights. However, this approach may not always yield the anticipated results. Contrary to the common belief that stretching boundaries foster growth, there is growing evidence to suggest that leaders setting unrealistic expectations can lead to not only failure in meeting those expectations but also a host of other unwelcome consequences. Such a leadership style can undermine team morale, erode trust in leadership, and even result in long-term damage to the organization's performance. This article delves into the reasons why unrealistic expectations from leaders cannot lead to realistic outcomes and provides insights into more effective leadership strategies.

An essential quality of any successful leader is the ability to inspire their team towards a shared vision. However, the gap between inspiration and execution is where the challenge lies, a gap that is widened when expectations set are far removed from practicality. Understanding this critical difference between setting high aspirations and unrealistic expectations is pivotal for effective leadership. Aspirations act as a compass, guiding teams towards a desired future state, while expectations serve as a roadmap, outlining the specific, achievable steps towards that state. 

Unrealistic expectations blur this roadmap, leaving employees stranded in a landscape of confusion, stress, and possible failure. As we delve deeper into the core of this discussion, it's essential to unpack the adverse effects of unrealistic expectations and explore how leaders can maintain a healthy balance between challenging and achievable goals.

Understanding Unrealistic Expectations

Unrealistic expectations are goals or benchmarks that are virtually unachievable within the provided resources and timeframe. While it's crucial for leaders to challenge their teams and inspire them to push their limits, these expectations must always be grounded in reality. Unrealistic expectations can lead to anxiety and stress among employees, resulting in a drop in productivity and, ultimately, poor performance.

Moreover, a continuous pattern of unmet expectations can lead to a sense of frustration and mistrust among the team members. It can also create a toxic work environment where employees are more focused on meeting impossible targets rather than focusing on quality, innovation, and collaboration.

The Disconnect between Expectations and Outcomes

When expectations are sky-high, leaders often overlook the constraints of time, resources, and employee capabilities. The pressure to meet such expectations can lead to corner-cutting, subpar work, and even unethical practices, as employees scramble to meet their targets. In the long run, this can seriously damage the company's reputation and its relationships with customers and partners.

Furthermore, the constant pressure can lead to burnout, high employee turnover, and low morale, all of which negatively impact productivity. The psychological impact on the team can be severe, leading to a lack of motivation and a drop in overall performance. Eventually, the actual outcomes fall drastically short of the desired outcomes, leading to a cycle of underperformance.

The Power of Realistic Expectations

The goal of a leader should not be to set high expectations for the sake of it. Instead, the aim should be to set achievable, yet challenging goals that motivate employees to stretch their abilities without feeling overwhelmed. Realistic goals convey the message that the leader understands the capabilities and constraints of the team and that they trust their team to deliver to the best of their ability.

Realistic expectations lead to tangible outcomes. They foster a sense of achievement and motivation among employees, which in turn boosts productivity and promotes a positive work environment. Moreover, they lead to high-quality work, as employees can focus on the task at hand without worrying about impossible deadlines. This ultimately contributes to the company's growth and success in the long term.

Creating a Balance

It is critical for leaders to strike a balance between challenging and realistic expectations. Leaders should involve their teams in the goal-setting process, ensuring goals are not only aligned with the organization's strategic objectives but also take into account the team's abilities and resources. This encourages a sense of ownership and commitment among team members, leading to higher engagement and better results.


Leadership is not about painting grand visions that are detached from reality. It is about guiding the team towards a better future by setting achievable goals and providing the necessary support to meet those goals. While ambition and high aspirations are essential for growth, they need to be grounded in realism to be truly effective. Leaders who set unrealistic expectations may seem to drive progress in the short term, but they risk damaging the morale, productivity, and trust of their teams in the long run. 

On the other hand, leaders who set realistic expectations create an environment of trust, motivation, and productivity. They understand the capabilities of their teams and inspire them to reach their true potential without overwhelming them. Ultimately, effective leadership hinges on the ability to set realistic expectations that align with the team's abilities and the organization's objectives. Only then can leaders achieve the desired outcomes and drive sustained growth for the organization. In the world of leadership, reality may be challenging, but it is certainly more rewarding. After all, the power to inspire, motivate, and achieve lies in setting realistic expectations and then exceeding them.

bottom of page